Anyone can have an opinion about a pitch. Almost nobody's opinion is worth acting on, and there's normally no way to tell the difference — so feedback arrives as an undifferentiated pile and the founder has to guess who to believe.
Here, you earn the right to review. Twelve pairs, each one campaign that funded and one that didn't. Your accuracy becomes your reviewer rating, and that rating decides where your review sits in someone's inbox.
The rating is not a reward for showing up. It expires after six months, and it moves when the campaigns you reviewed either fund or don't.
Creator name, location and links are stripped. You'll see them after you submit — not before.
This is the part that gets scored. When the campaign closes, your call is checked against what actually happened.
Not scored, and it's the part the founder actually reads. Vague encouragement helps nobody and will sink your usefulness rating.
The founder never sees your name — only your tier. You'll see who they are as soon as you submit.
Sorted by reviewer rating. Founders read top-down and most stop after three, which is why the rating matters more than anything else in this system.
Your prediction is now recorded against this campaign. When it closes in 39 days, your rating moves — up if you called it, down if you didn't. Predictions you never resolve don't count for anything.